Snowplow Forums banner

1 - 20 of 101 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,565 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Let’s play a hypothetical game— you own a 3 mile dirt road with a series of elevation changes from the county road level where the termination point of the dirt road is 50ft below the county road and highest point is 100ft above the road level. The upward slope is 7.5% grade and the descending the grade is 15%. The location is near a lake with high levels of moist snow with lots of icing. However, since this a dirt road the hypothetical home owner only wants to use sand and no salt.

Problem: to add traction to the roadway the hypothetical person has been using hand sanding method.
Reason: budget for a new equipment is $1500 or less for sand spreader
Goal: reduce the sanding time
Dilemma: all the spreaders in my price range work best with salt. Salt will damage the roadway. Sand will provide the needed traction...

Solution?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
270 Posts
Here, $1000

https://hudsonvalley.craigslist.org/hvo/d/fishkill-buyers-stainless-steel-sander/6935265231.html

Does say some TLC needed but it leaves plenty of your budget left and, hell, its July so you can probably get it for $500. And obviously we know you like a good project.

Too busy rebuilding a really old truck? No worries. Here is another option in your area

https://hudsonvalley.craigslist.org/hvo/d/cold-spring-8-foot-ice-way-salt-sander/6921089552.html

That one has only been used twice since rebuild. It is a bit over your budget at $2000, but again it's July so I'm sure there is some wiggle room there.

Kudos to having the foresight to look well before the season. Now is the time for bargains.

Of course, for $1500 you could just buy a used Walter and alleviate the need for sand since traction would no longer be an issue. And you'd probably have enough change to buy a Happy Meal on the very slow drive home. Maybe the toy inside will be a Bernie bobblehead.

That's ok, no need to thank me. I'm here to help.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
699 Posts
Hypothetically now we’re supposed to play your word games. ?

Get out of the basement let a little reality shine on your face .

Go buy a hypothetical truck with hypothetical traction.

What a moron does he really think this is a helpful contribution to the forum ?
Try baseing it in reality.

What a tool
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
270 Posts
What a moron does he really think this is a helpful contribution to the forum ?
Of course he doesn't. It was directed at me. It was an attempt at a private dig. Emphasis on "attempt."

Mind you, he rails endlessly about the inside jokes over at PS and how detrimental they are to the forum. Unless he is the one making them that is. Then, well, that's different.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
699 Posts
Of course he doesn't. It was directed at me. It was an attempt at a private dig. Emphasis on "attempt."

Mind you, he rails endlessly about the inside jokes over at PS and how detrimental they are to the forum. Unless he is the one making them that is. Then, well, that's different.
So his nonsense is an attempt to troll and
Harass the membership?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,565 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
Here, $1000

https://hudsonvalley.craigslist.org/hvo/d/fishkill-buyers-stainless-steel-sander/6935265231.html

Does say some TLC needed but it leaves plenty of your budget left and, hell, its July so you can probably get it for $500. And obviously we know you like a good project.

Too busy rebuilding a really old truck? No worries. Here is another option in your area

https://hudsonvalley.craigslist.org/hvo/d/cold-spring-8-foot-ice-way-salt-sander/6921089552.html

That one has only been used twice since rebuild. It is a bit over your budget at $2000, but again it's July so I'm sure there is some wiggle room there.

Kudos to having the foresight to look well before the season. Now is the time for bargains.

Of course, for $1500 you could just buy a used Walter and alleviate the need for sand since traction would no longer be an issue. And you'd probably have enough change to buy a Happy Meal on the very slow drive home. Maybe the toy inside will be a Bernie bobblehead.

That's ok, no need to thank me. I'm here to help.
those could all be good options. However, we all know if I were the person in this scenario it would be a 5-7yard sander for my Walter trucks. I am curious why you believe each person will knock 50% or more off the units? I would surmise even if it is July most people will only drop 35% off the sales price at best. Then you have the condition of each unit.

The more expensive one does seem better but since being-rebuilt and recently serviced are vague terms both in scope of work or in a temporal sense. The question is what was rebuilt when and what do you mean exactly by serviced? Did it get grease, new spark plugs or was it more major work?

Either way you presuppose that our hypothetical snow operator is mechanically inclined to much of this on his or her own or that any repairs will be rather minor in scope. Two assumptions I wouldn’t make.

So, let’s expand this scenario a bit more with some information about the hypothetical user of the sander. Let’s say his/her truck is a short box 2005 GMC 1500 series truck. Let’s say this person has no other means of loading said spreader but with a shovel. And let’s say they would prefer a tailgate sander?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,565 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
,

Of course he doesn't. It was directed at me. It was an attempt at a private dig. Emphasis on "attempt."

Mind you, he rails endlessly about the inside jokes over at PS and how detrimental they are to the forum. Unless he is the one making them that is. Then, well, that's different.
Not a dig at all... I am curious if you will be consistent in your advice. That is really all and I want to see what other posters will come up with.

Again, you are misconstruing my statements I have nothing against inside jokes. I find it amusing that after a year you still think saying 100% traction or 4 point positive traction along with occasional Walter this is hysterical. A good design is a good design no matter what. The real people that continually started issues were people like you and few others.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
270 Posts
those could all be good options. However, we all know if I were the person in this scenario it would be a 5-7yard sander for my Walter trucks. I am curious why you believe each person will knock 50% or more off the units? I would surmise even if it is July most people will only drop 35% off the sales price at best. Then you have the condition of each unit.
Since I make my living selling stuff like this, I know that anyone selling a fixer-upper (which is what TLC is code for) in July would likely be willing to move quite a bit if they actually got any sucker looking to buy. And since our budget is $1500, even at full pop, that leaves $500 for service. Anything less than the $1000 is even more money.

That is on the $1000 special. At no point did I suggest that someone would move 50% on the $2000 one, only that you only need to get closer to the hypothetical $1500 budget. Advanced math with my abacus from the other thread tells me that's only 25% needed, not 35%. And I'll assume that even if you couldn't get them down the full 25%, since it's July you have plenty of time to save your pennies and/or search for a better deal.


The more expensive one does seem better but since being-rebuilt and recently serviced are vague terms both in scope of work or in a temporal sense. The question is what was rebuilt when and what do you mean exactly by serviced? Did it get grease, new spark plugs or was it more major work?
Beats the hell out of me. I guess if this weren't all an exercise in time wasting and you actually were interested in either of them, then you would call the seller and find that stuff out.

Either way you presuppose that our hypothetical snow operator is mechanically inclined to much of this on his or her own or that any repair
s will be rather minor in scope. Two assumptions I wouldn’t make.
No, you'd tell them to get tire chains.

So, let’s expand this scenario a bit more with some information about the hypothetical user of the sander. Let’s say his/her truck is a short box 2005 GMC 1500 series truck. Let’s say this person has no other means of loading said spreader but with a shovel. And let’s say they would prefer a tailgate sander?
Thanks for the offer, but I'll take a hard pass on dragging this out any further.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
699 Posts
“Either way you presuppose that our hypothetical snow operator is mechanically inclined “

No , in my world he’s completely able to maintain his 14-year-old 1500 . .
But he realizes that his 1500 isn’t up to the task so he’s going to traded in on a new 2500 pick up or he’s going to hire it out .

He also has a weatherproof shed with climate control and was able to get sand ithat was completely dry so it didn’t freeze on him in the winter time.

Maybe he should just invest in vehicles they have traction control as they have 100% traction.

Troll'en, troll’en , troll’en
( Sung to the song “raw hide”
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,565 Posts
Discussion Starter #14
Hypothetically now we’re supposed to play your word games. ?

Get out of the basement let a little reality shine on your face .

Go buy a hypothetical truck with hypothetical traction.

What a moron does he really think this is a helpful contribution to the forum ?
Try baseing it in reality.

What a tool
Really none of this is based in reality?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,565 Posts
Discussion Starter #15
Hypothetically now we’re supposed to play your word games. ?

Get out of the basement let a little reality shine on your face .

Go buy a hypothetical truck with hypothetical traction.

What a moron does he really think this is a helpful contribution to the forum ?
Try baseing it in reality.

What a tool
What isn’t real about this scenario?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,565 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
“Either way you presuppose that our hypothetical snow operator is mechanically inclined “

No , in my world he’s completely able to maintain his 14-year-old 1500 . .
But he realizes that his 1500 isn’t up to the task so he’s going to traded in on a new 2500 pick up or he’s going to hire it out .

He also has a weatherproof shed with climate control and was able to get sand ithat was completely dry so it didn’t freeze on him in the winter time.

Maybe he should just invest in vehicles they have traction control as they have 100% traction.

Troll'en, troll’en , troll’en
( Sung to the song “raw hide”
Well, this was based on a real world scenario and in it the operator only had 1500 series truck. He had no way to load his spreader and didn’t have climate controlled sand storage. Or at least he never claimed to. All of this scenario with a few minor details are based on statements. They just aren’t mine.

Actually this hypothetical could create interesting conversations about spreader tech and medium choices along cost effective solutions for storage and maintenance.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
699 Posts
From Cambridge the only definition of any word that’s factual, comes from Cambridge ....

Hypothetical
imagined or suggested but not necessarily real or true:

I’m just here to help ....
 
1 - 20 of 101 Posts
Top