Snowplow Forums banner

1 - 11 of 11 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Hello,

This is my first post and potentially an explosive one to Chevy, Ford, Dodge or Toyota supporters.

We bought a nice piece of property in S.Bristol, NY and it has about a 1/4 mile long relatively flat driveway. I need to buy a truck to tow my 22' aluminum fishing boat and I would like to plow my driveway in the winter with a decent dependable rig.

I guess I'm looking for a tow truck and a plow I can attach and detach myself that's not too complicated to use and that's dependable. I'm also torn between buying a 1/2 ton or a 3/4 ton truck. My son tells me the 3/4 ton truck have beefier transmissions then the 1/2 tons have especially since he needed to replace his babied 2014 silverado transmission when it hit 100,000 miles.

Personally, I'm not into all of the new gadgets bells and whistles these new trucks have and I would much rather buy something older, simpler and more reliable that doesn't cost a fortune to repair and something I can maintain myself in my shop. All suggestions would be most welcome. SH
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
290 Posts
Theres an awful lot of issues there for a "simple" question

In general, a 3/4 will always be heavier duty and take more abuse than a 1/2 ton. 1/2 tons are personal use trucks. That said, I wont say that a 1/2 wont work for personal use plowing and towing a 12' boat.

I'm not sure what you mean by "complicated to use" - I gather you are imagining modern plows work like an iPhone with all sorts of techno stuff. They arent. A modern plow will work with modern trucks. Itll be much easier to take on and off. And parts availability wont be an issue. An old, obsolete plow will be much tougher to take off, you may not be able to adapt it to modern trucks, and parts to fix it when it breaks may not be available. Old plows are not inherently more reliable.

Not to mention, buying used plows can end up being money pits if you arent very familiar with the plows and know what itll cost you to equip the truck which can top $2k in some cases before you've even bought a plow.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
Thank you for the advice.

From what you are suggesting a 3/4 truck would probably be the safest plow/truck to get because of the added abuse it will probably take. Now if you only had @ $12,000 to spend on a truck and plow combo, and didn't care about the creature comforts, year, make or "style" of the truck, are there any recommendations you could give to this first time truck/plow owner??
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
290 Posts
Thank you for the advice.

From what you are suggesting a 3/4 truck would probably be the safest plow/truck to get because of the added abuse it will probably take. Now if you only had @ $12,000 to spend on a truck and plow combo, and didn't care about the creature comforts, year, make or "style" of the truck, are there any recommendations you could give to this first time truck/plow owner??
Short answer? No.

Long answer: $12,000 to buy a plow and truck doesn't really give you a lot to work with. Since we are talking very-used, it really depends on what is available in your area, in your price range. I have no idea what that is. Luckily being July you have plenty of time to shop. Ideally I'd want to stay in the 2000s. Anything early than 2000, plow-wise at least, will likely lead to headaches & parts availability. Obviously, the newer the better both on truck and plow. Your best bet would be to find a plow and truck for sale together. Trying to buy them separate will be trickier since you aren't likely to know the true value of the plow or the final cost unless you are very familiar with them.

Avoid pseudo-plows like snowbear and the like which uses winches and that kind of crap but you aren't likely to find one of those on a 3/4 ton. Also, ideally you'll want a plow who there is a local dealer for, so you should probably look into what is around in your area.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Totally agree with cwren, 12k does is not much of a budget for truck/plow combo. I just put a new plow on my 3/4 ton ford 2 weeks ago, $8300 out the door. With something really used your also buying someone else’s problems with it. You don’t want to be out there at 3am working on your plow in the snow and cold ( they never break down in front of the shop lol)

This time of year you can get some really decent deals on new plows, wait a couple months when everyone is getting new plows for the up coming season and the price will jump. You don’t need anything as big or beefy as what I just bought (SnowEx 9’6” HDV) but a decent snowdogg, western, or such straight blade would do you fine.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
Thank you both for the advice. 3/4 ton, newer than 2000 with a plow that can get serviced locally and obviously the newer the better. Any preference on vehicle types since this will be my working truck and it mostly will be used to plow (my own driveway) tow and haul materials pretty much within a 30 mile radius from our home. I have had only Chevys all my life but I am willing to change brands if Dodge or Fords are proven more reliable when it comes to work trucks.

Someone suggested I can use a plow on a 4x4 suburban since my driveway is fairly level and that option would give me the ability to take my family out. Any thoughts on that??

Again thanks so much for the input, I can only buy one vehicle for this job and since I'll keep it until the wheels fall off, I need alot of help choosing the right one.

SH
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Thank you both for the advice. 3/4 ton, newer than 2000 with a plow that can get serviced locally and obviously the newer the better. Any preference on vehicle types since this will be my working truck and it mostly will be used to plow (my own driveway) tow and haul materials pretty much within a 30 mile radius from our home. I have had only Chevys all my life but I am willing to change brands if Dodge or Fords are proven more reliable when it comes to work trucks.

Someone suggested I can use a plow on a 4x4 suburban since my driveway is fairly level and that option would give me the ability to take my family out. Any thoughts on that??

Again thanks so much for the input, I can only buy one vehicle for this job and since I'll keep it until the wheels fall off, I need alot of help choosing the right one.

SH
That’s a loaded question and subject to a heated debate lol. I’m partial to Ford Super Duty trucks, can’t stand their cars, but to me they have never let me down on the 3/4 tons and 1 tons. Basically falls down to user preferences.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
290 Posts
^____ what he said

Yes, you can do a 3/4 suburban but those are pretty rare beasts. The vast majority will be 1/2 ton. Oh, and it's the size of an ocean liner. As long as that's your thing, go for it.

A quad cab p/u will do the same job and be easier to find used, so long as you dont actually need the 8-passenger thing.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
OK
That is good advice,,,I did not know suburbans came in 3/4 ton sizes, I thought they all were 1/2 ton with 2W, 4W or AWD versions. You two have been very helpful and I'll do my best to come up with a decent plow/truck combo.

SH
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
Hello
I'll be looking at a GMC 2500 with 136,000 miles with a Western plow tomorrow. I looked the truck over Tuesday but he had the plow at a different location. It ran well and except for the fuel level sensor code and airbag light it seemed to run pretty well. I ran a carfax on the vehicle and there is a solid history of oil, transmission fluid changes, tire rotations and nothing that out of the ordinary for the maintained of a work truck which he used primarily for towing a "pot hole filling" trailer.
With the plow attached to the truck, how would anyone recommend a road test to make sure the 4W drive works properly and the functions of the plow work. I'm not familiar with the problems associated with trucks or plows and the 4W drive systems so any road test tips for tomorrow would be appreciated.

Thanks always for helping rookie out!!

SH
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
98 Posts
You do not need a plow to test for 4x4. Put it in 4hi and then try and make a tight turn, if it works it will bind and hop. Could also try and get into soft ground and see if you can spin all the tires.
 
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
Top